Topic: Strategic managerial accounting
- Strategic management accounting
- Concepts of Strategic Management Accounting
- Assumptions of Strategic management accounting
- Management Accounting for Decision-making
- Different models of strategic management accounting
- Analytical Skills for Strategic Management Accounting
- Key techniques to help to make planning for the management decisions making:
- ROI for the performance measure of an organization
- Contribution of ROI for decision making:
- Economic Value Added (EVA)’
- Contribution of EVA for decision making:
- Supporting the comment
- Short-term orientation of ROI and the EVA & recommendation to remove that orientation
- Transfer pricing
- Objectives of Transfer Pricing
- Market based transfer prices
- Negotiated transfer prices
- Full cost transfer prices
- Cost-plus a mark-up transfer prices
- Transfer price within an organization for decision making
- Decision making process is helped by the transfer price through following way:
- Limitations of transfer pricing
In this assignment, I will go
for the critical analysis of different fundamental issues of strategic
management accounting. Not only that but also I will go for the application of
strategic issues of the strategic man
agent accounting. To the analysis, I am assigned to a specific topic to be
investigated on the light of the concept of the strategic management
accounting. To make the proper investigation and analysis, I will apply some
core concepts models and principles to facilitate my study. I will also
identify the shortcomings of the different approaches and I will go for the overcoming
the shortcomings. Everything will be done based on my personal consideration of
significance
Part-A
Before presenting my about the
prescribed thought I will go for the critical review of the different thoughts
concepts and models & their
suitability of the application which will support my opinion regarding the
precise but highly important matter among the business all over the world.
These are prescribed in the subsequent parts.
A structure of management
accounting within which highlighting is placed on information which relates
towards factors exterior to the entity, in addition to non-financial
information as well as within generated information is the definition of strategic
management accounting. Towards
offer a forward looking model that assists management within making company
decisions, the integration of strategic business objectives through management
accounting information is the strategic management accounting (McKinnon, & Bruns, 2003)..
Management Accounting Goals: A number of goals are contained by management
accounting. Management of the corporation budget is one of its main concerns.
Assigning Costs Outside of Main Offering: Towards
estimate the costs, managers who are concerned within the whole picture also
need. Follow-through plus marketplace
analysis, The products acquire postproduction the costs of customer service.
Competitor Comparison: Towards scrutinize the costs of other
businesses in the same industry; an absolute management accounting system will
also have scope.
Strategic Production: Particularly in favour of manufacturing industries, strategic
production is the fundamentals of management accounting. Businesses save
currency plus wait sharp is helped by this.
Basic Goal Assumptions: A specific of
type of goal is required in management accounting. Though, management will at
all times attempt towards achieve an acceptable level of income whatsoever form
the goal takes (Kaplan, & Norton, 2002).
Role of Management Assumptions: Principally upon
the skill plus abilities of management which skills can differ extensively
amongst dissimilar managers is dependent through the achievement of the
business. Management makes utilize of exact planning as well as control
concepts and techniques so as to attain desired results (Hayes,
& Abernathy, 2000).
Decision-making Assumptions: Decision‑
making is a significant managerial purpose. As marketing, production, plus
financial, decision which management must create may be classify.
Accounting Department Assumptions: A prime
foundation of information essential in making decisions is the accounting subdivision.
Nature of Accounting Information: It is essential
towards distinguish connecting fixed as well as changeable costs plus other
types of costs that are not significant in the footage of business transactions
so as to the accounting department towards make significant examination of data.
Decision-making may be merely definite
as choosing a path of action since amongst alternatives within strategic
management accounting. The one that involves the most proceeds or the least
quantity of cost is a foundation assumption is that the best choice. In the
following process of strategic management accounting (Horngren, Foster, & Datar, 2007)).
ü
For
a specified type of decision, recognize a variety of alternatives.
ü
To
assess a variety of alternatives, gain the essential data necessary.
ü
The
consequences of each alternative will be analyzed plus resolute.
ü
For
achieving the desired result, the alternative will be selected.
ü
The
selected substitute will be implemented.
ü
Evaluation
of the results of the decisions alongside standards or other wanted results at a
suitable time.
There are 2 basic models of the
strategic accounting which assist to make the appropriate decision for the
profit maximization, reducing uncertainty in investment and provide a clear and
easy way for the achievement of the organizational short-term and long-term goals (Hansen, & Mowen, 1997).
Profit maximization model:
The logical behaviour of
equilibrium postulation is profit maximization. At profit maximization model,
any firm aiming will go for raising its output till it reaches maximum profit production.
Dissimilarity among whole revenue plus full amount of cost is profit.
Marris Growth
Maximization Model:
The model has been developed by
Robin Marris. Through both the manager in addition to the shareholders
contemporary firms are managed consistent with this theory. Maximize the rate
of growth of the definite is aspire of the manager whereas maximizing the
dividend in addition to the increasing the share price is the aim of the
shareholders.
Sales Maximization
Model:
For profit maximization model,
this is alternative model. With W.J. Baumol, an American Economist, the model
has been propounded. Relativity concerning business behaviour is the supposition
within this theory. In maximizing sales rather than earnings, managers are more
concerned. It was the thought of Baumol.
Shareholder Wealth Maximization
Model
The purpose of a firm’s
management should be to maximize the present value of the accepted future cash
flows towards impartiality owners is the settled goal through the
Shareholder-Wealth Maximization model.
A
completely different accounting method from financial accounting is strategic management
accounting. Whilst the latter prepares financial information mainly in favour
of internal plus external stakeholders, the former focuses on interior production
operations. An exact set of logical skills nearby plus globally is required by
strategic management accounting (McKinnon, & Bruns, 2003)..
Critical
Thinking:
Critical thinking is analytical
skill. While all individuals have natural critical thinking skills, strategic
managerial accountants must focus their critical thinking on financial
information.
Mathematical
Fundamental skills for example
subtraction, addition, multiplication plus division are included in these capabilities.
Glean the essential figures as of them and decide the answer for items for
instance objective cost or price, management accountants must be capable towards
obtain manifold bits of information (McKinnon, & Bruns, 2003)..
Aptitude
When obtaining an official
accounting degree, ability skills narrate to those abilities an personage
learns. Frequently accounting, business finance, cost behaviour plus general
management courses are built-in in curriculum.
Identification
Identifying costs plus where
they belong in the universal ledger is a bulky part of the job within
management accounting. Direct costs, straight labour plus manufacturing
overhead, which hold both variable plus fixed costs, are included in examples.
Attention to
Detail
All accounting performance
necessitates attention towards detail in spite of classification or type. Towards
gross misrepresentations of a company's monetary information, wrong categorization
of just one cost item can guide.
Key techniques to help the
management for generating information to make decision for the profit and
wealth maximization are like following:
Return on investment (ROI):
To appraise
the competence of an investment or to evaluate the competence of a quantity of
dissimilar investments, it is a performance calculation. The result is
articulated as a percentage or a ratio, towards compute ROI, the advantage of
an investment is alienated through the cost of the investment (Campbell, 2005)
The return on investment formula:
Figure: ROI
It is very much important for an organization to
measure organizational performance. For measuring organizational performance,
there are three crucial matters for the performance measurement of an
organization which can be extracted from ROI. These are to know the:
Rate of earnings of total capital employed
Rate of earnings on invested capital
Rate of earnings on proprietary equity and stock equity
With total
liabilities, net income, interest, in addition to taxes are alienated for
measuring the rate of earnings of total capital employed. With proprietary
equity plus fixed liabilities, the net income plus income taxes are alienated for
measuring rate of earnings on invested capital. With total capital plus
reserves towards calculate net income will be alienated on behalf of measuring
the rate of earnings on proprietary equity plus stock equity (McKinnon, & Bruns, 2003).
The investment should be not be occupied, if an
investment does not have a optimistic ROI, or else if there are other chances
with a higher ROI.
For example:
An investor buys $1,000 worth of stocks and sells the shares
1 year later for $1,200. The net profit from
the investment would be $200 and the ROI would be calculated as follows:
ROI
= (200 / 1,000) x 100 = 20%
The ROI in
the example above would be 20%.
If the tax is $250 on this
income prevails, than the ROI will be
ROI= (180/1000) x100= 18%
ROI gives different performance
related information for the organizational management to make the more accurate
and effective decision within the organization.
Its theoretical foundation is
not, although EVA is reasonably new-fangled to the financial press. Through the
consulting firm Stem Stewart & Company, term EVA was recently copyrighted. On
value formation, EVA is a revolutionary concept, as well as to abolish most of
the performance evaluation trouble besieging corporations it is most probable. On
accounting conventions, most performance assessment methods rely a lot which
can simply be manipulated. But throughout the employ of economic concepts, EVA
focuses the concentration of managers on value creating performance (McKinnon,
& Bruns, 2003)..
The investment within assets
required to produce that income, in addition to the cost of the investment in
assets EVA is financial performances calculate rooted in operating income
following taxes.
Within scheming EVA, the three
elements are used like following:
Operating
income after tax,
Investment
in assets
The
cost of capital
The formula to measure EVA is:
Example:
Assume that Company XYZ has the following
components to use in the EVA formula:
NOPAT = $3,380,000
Capital Investment = $1,300,000
WACC = .056 or 5.60%
Capital Investment = $1,300,000
WACC = .056 or 5.60%
EVA = $3,380,000 - ($1,300,000 x
.056) = $3,307,200
EVA is a financial performance
measure based on operating income after taxes, the investment in assets
required to generate that income, and the cost of the investment in assets which
make the decision making process of management more accurate.
From the above discussion we can say that the
ROI & EVA are the two common features of strategic managerial accounting to
make the strategic managerial decisions for the financial projection. For that
reason we can easily support the following comment (Kaplan, & Norton,
2002).
"Both Return on investment
(ROI) and Economic Value Added (EVA), when used as performance measures in an
organisation, encourage managers to be short-term in their focus and decision
making".
There are different a
limitation of ROI & EVA approaches. One of the most important limitation of
the approach is these are a measure which is short term oriented. These focus
on the short term financial performance measurement (Johnson, & Kaplan, 2003).)..
ROI:
To remove the short term focus problem the ROI will be in
the nature of the long-term calculation. To do so, long-term costs such as maintenance, support, and software
upgrades are overlooked will be included in it which may lead the perfect
decision investment decisions for the project selection.
EVA:
To remove the short term
orientation of EVA in this approach some additional features will be included
in it which will also consider the future consideration of the facts which will
be helpful for the future prediction. It will enable the managers to check the
future validity of the financial result as well as the current predictions.
Part-B
When selling goods or services
among corporation divisions plus departments or among a parent company in
addition to subsidiary, transfer pricing methods are applied this are the rates
or prices. May be the original procure price of the merchandise in question or
a rate that is abridged because of internal depreciation, the pricing is set in
favour of the exchange. It can assist to more capably manage profit as well as
loss ratios in the company when used correctly. Usually, amongst the overall
business family, transfer pricing is measured to be a comparatively simple
method of moving goods plus services (Johnson,
& Kaplan, 2003).
Figure: transfer price mechanism
Regularly
in dissimilar countries, corporation with dispersed production facilities, use
transfer pricing. Over or undercharging in favour of goods sold among branches
at a price dogged through the company is included by it. To take advantage of
different tax rates between countries is the main objective. To appraise
performance of divisions within a corporation, transfer pricing also is applied (Horngren,
Foster, & Datar, 2007).
Tax
Savings
Through the transfer pricing
the organization can save the tax expense. Like in one multinational
corporation, some goods are produced in a subsidiary where the tax rate is very
high. But if the company transfer the goods to that division where national tax
is very low, the tax amount will be ultimately reduced.
Boost
Profits
A company can save currency on
customs duties paid through the branch within the importing country with
undercharging in favour of goods crossing national limits. In opposition, a corporation
can take out more currency from a nation with tighter cash outflow restrictions
through overcharging.
Measure
Performance
How their individual divisions
are performing, business require to know. Transfer pricing is a method of
measuring. A corporation can measure the productivity of every division plus
settle on where to create organizational adjustments through setting a price
for goods within every stage of the production procedure.
Arm’s
Length Standard
Through most developed
countries is that on behalf of transactions among branches a company should use
marketplace prices, the essential principle of this benchmark are used. Particularly
when a corporation has branches in many countries, enforcement of this rule is complex.
Example of transfer price calculation:
Figure: TF
To employ the market price is
the simplest in addition to most stylish transfer price. The upstream
subsidiary can sell either inside or outwardly plus make the similar profit
with either alternative, through doing so. Rather than being topic towards the
odd profit vagaries that can happen beneath mandated pricing schemes, it can
also make the uppermost probable profit (Horngren,
Foster, & Datar, 2007).
Without using any market price
as a baseline, it may be required towards negotiate a transfer price among
subsidiaries. When there is no perceptible market price since the market is extremely
small or the goods are extremely tailored, this circumstance arises. The relation
negotiating skills of the parties are the foundation of this result within
prices (Hayes, & Abernathy, 2000).
Example of the market-based & negotiated
transfer price:
Figure:
market based and negotiated transfer price
Sources: www.bdo.uk.com
It may be foolish towards
always set transfer price accurately at the changeable costs of production; it
is applied inside an imperfect market. For example: prices do not offer for the
substitution of permanent assets. On total amalgamation cost to make sure that
it will give a contribution to wrap the fixed overheads, the Supply Division
will desire to bottom the transfer price. Since managers necessitate an
estimate of long-run marginal price in favour of decision-making, full-cost
based transfer price is extensively used. Though, to supply poor estimates of
long-run trivial cost for decision-making, usual amalgamation costing systems are
apt (Hansen, & Mowen, 1997).
A firm could think using a
system that creates a transfer price rooted in the cost of the mechanism
being transferred, if there is no marketplace price at all on which to bottom a
relocate price where the company accumulate the criterion cost of a
constituent, add a criterion profit margin, and use the consequence as the move
price, the most excellent way towards do this is to add a margin on the cost (Campbell, 2005).
Examples full-cost and cost plus transfer
price
Figure: full cost and cost plus transfer price
Inside the organizations, the innermost management
takes the dissimilar strategic decisions. They require the performance
connected information of the organization in favour of that explanation. Controlling
in addition to monitoring is required towards attain the information the business.
An innermost management cannot monitor plus control all the process parameters
of each subunit within a great organization. This is why large organizations
are typically divorced into divisions. To obtain all essential action, each
division is an independent unit plus its manager has the liberty. But, the
performance of the division managers, a decentralized business has complexity
for evaluating. In addition, organize the activities of the divisions towards
make the most of the organization's total income, the innermost management of
the association needs. A method is necessary on behalf of measuring the payment
of each division towards the total income of the organization so as to assess
the performance of every division. From one separation towards another, an ordinary
solution to this difficulty is to put prices for middle goods which are
transferred. Since transfer prices, these prices are recognized. Transfer
prices are mainly used (Brinker,
2005).
Anchored in the profits that he produces, towards assess
division managers' performance.
decisions
Similar to the pricing of the concluding product,
towards allow the divisions to take decisions
Provides the divisional independence
Because of the manager’s
closeness to local circumstances, decisions are improved plus timely.
Through routine, restricted
decision trouble, top managers are not unfocused.
Because they have additional
manage over results, managers’ motivation increases.
For managers for senior stage positions within the future, augmented
decision making provides better training.
ü Within dissimilar parts of the business, be short of of goal congruence amongst
managers
ü Towards top management, inadequate information available for making
decisions
ü Amongst managers unresponsive parts of the business, be short of of
coordination
In this assignment, I have gone
for the critical analysis of different fundamental issues of strategic
management accounting. Not only that but also I have gone for the application
of strategic issues of the strategic
man agent accounting. To the analysis, I was assigned to a specific topic to be
investigated on the light of the concept of the strategic management
accounting. To make the proper investigation and analysis, I applied some core
concepts models and principles to facilitate my study. I also identified the
shortcomings of the different approaches and I have gone for the overcoming the
shortcomings. Everything have been done on this assignment based on my personal
consideration of significance
1)
Brinker, B.
(Ed.). (2005). Handbook of Cost Management. Boston, MA: Warren Gorham
Lamont.
2)
Campbell, R.
(2005). I, 31-36.
3)
Hansen, D.,
& Mowen, M. (1997). Cost management: Accounting and control.
Cincinnati, OH: Southwestern Publishing.
4)
Hayes, R.,
& Abernathy, W. (2000). Managing our way to economic decline.
Harvard Business Review, 67-77.
5)
Horngren, C.,
Foster, G., & Datar, S. (2007). Cost accounting: A managerial emphasis.
Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
6)
Johnson, T.,
& Kaplan, R. (2003). Relevance lost: The rise and fall of management
accounting. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
7)
Kaplan, R.,
& Norton, D. (2002). The balanced scorecard - Measures that drive
performance. Harvard Business Review, 71-79.
8)
McKinnon,
S., & Bruns, W. (2003). What production managers really want to know.
Management Accounting, 29-35.
No comments:
Post a Comment